Prefer to listen? You’ll find an original audio recording here. ⬆️


I’ve been publishing weekly here for close to five years now and have rarely missed a deadline. That says more about my inclination to please than it does my diligence. I need to think of myself as someone who upholds her end of a bargain, even when I’m the one laying the ground rules. In that time, my writing has evolved, and some of the processes have become a little more predictable, but I don’t expect to ever stop learning from, and about, this craft.
With that in mind, you might think I’d be prepared to explain what I write when the question comes up in casual conversation. Alas.
Not long ago, after a local book talk, I found myself in a brief exchange with the woman who had interviewed the author. Mary Beth Durkin is an award-winning PBS producer, among other achievements, which is to say, she is a professional at asking good questions. We’d first crossed paths back in my farming days. A lively fall bonfire and the farm’s owners brought us together back then, and it was the same mutual friend who reconnected us this time. At the back of the small theater, refreshing our memories and swapping pleasantries, the dialogue came around to writing and then to the moment of truth.
“What do you write about?” she asked.
I felt a familiar hesitation rise in my throat before tumbling into a cascade of words about goodness, the human condition, and how to find me on Substack, all of which I’m sure she promptly forgot. In the days since, I’ve not stopped thinking about our conversation.
Between a detailed analysis of my inadequacy for not having a better response, and a loop of mental replays that would give the I Love Lucy candy factory scene a run for its money, I received additional downloads from the universe, or whichever superpower occasionally orchestrates these teachable moments on repeat, like practice sentences from second grade.
The same week as the book talk, two otherwise insignificant remarks suddenly took on greater meaning. My friend and political writer extraordinaire, Ramona Grigg, left a warmhearted comment saying she never knows what she’s going to find when she visits my page. Soon after, describing my writing to someone nearby, another friend proclaimed, “She writes about...everything.”
So, what do I write about? And why is it so hard to offer a suitable answer? I’ve since held a private inquest, complete with a lineup and bad lighting. Three suspects emerged.
Suspect one: I never wrote the elevator speech. Five years of weekly essays and not one well-packaged sentence to deliver to a stranger, which is the writer’s version of being a cobbler’s child without shoes.
Suspect two: I don’t quite trust that anyone wants the real answer. “What do you write about?” can sound like an earnest question while really functioning as a courtesy, like “How are you?” The correct response is “Fine,” and I went long.
Suspect three is the one that holds up best under questioning. I think in connections, not categories, and I have yet to be bored by anything life has to offer, so any single label feels like shoes a size too small. I don’t like being pigeonholed.
We’re fond of categories. We like knowing what people do, where they’re from, who they know. It’s a way of sizing up and helping us decide whether there are commonalities worth pursuing. To meet expectations, algorithmic and otherwise, writers like me are encouraged to find a niche, develop a recognizable identity, and give readers a clear idea of what they’ll get when they subscribe. There’s some sense to this. If you’re looking for advice on growing tomatoes, you don’t want to read about the declining standards of restaurant manners. Although, come to think of it, there’s probably a connection.
Still, I’ve always been drawn to writers who don’t stay in one lane. David Sedaris can turn an ordinary encounter into an exercise in human absurdity and relevance. Anne Lamott writes about the glorious disorder of living, always finding hope without pretending everything is fine. Margaret Renkl illuminates the natural world and the possibility of persistent human decency. In her stories of friendship, death, love and bookstores, Ann Patchett writes about the relationships that shape us. Not one of them leaves me wondering whether they’ve lost their way when they wander into unfamiliar territory, because they always arrive with maps and lanterns.
I don’t believe we return to writers for their subjects. We’re there for their eyes, their distinctive ways of noticing, for the associations we might not make ourselves. We call our friends for the same reasons—to know what they’ll make of the latest boondoggle or the neighborhood brouhaha. We may come to expect a certain disposition, but we don’t demand it on a schedule. What we’re really after is familiarity and solidarity.
A lovely high school and college classmate of mine had a column in our hometown newspaper called “Out of My Head.” My friend faced more than her share of life’s unfairness, including a breast cancer diagnosis before she turned 40 and one for ovarian cancer a few years later. She lived well beyond what her doctors expected, and the world lost her bright light in 2024. I’ve shared the wisdom and delight of her column name with so many people over the years. Whatever she’d been turning over that week, you got it in her voice, and that was reason enough to read. It promised so little and delivered so much.
This is how I experience the world. A notion captures my attention. I muse, laugh, fret, remember what seemed long forgotten. Not infrequently, unrelated events turn out to have more in common than I anticipated, a blaring smoke alarm and a seizure-sniffing dog, for instance. The signage on every side road is the same: Pay Attention. Some weeks I’m smiling the whole way, some weeks I’m not, but I’m always looking for connections as I wind my way through the backroads.
To be sure, there’s plenty going wrong right now, and the evidence that we are in a collective free fall would be paralyzing were it not for the mitigating truth that kindness, ingenuity, courage, compassion, reverence, tenderness, grace—and extraordinary acts of goodness—still outweigh the destruction every single day. I am not one to manufacture happy endings or dress up hard truths in inspirational clothing. I’m here for the whole, complicated dance of being human. The human condition, as it were.
What I wish I’d said that day as the book talk ended is that I write about what catches my attention, and I trust it to lead us to places worth going. Then I’d ask Mary Beth what she’s working on next, because that’s the better question anyway.
I am alive in an incandescent time, and the world is filled with wonder. I never know what I’m going to find there!
~Elizabeth

It took about two weeks for me to come up with the answer I wish I’d had for Mary Beth. What is it about “best comebacks?” What I’ve come to appreciate is that it turned out to be a more useful question than I’d imagined, and I’m happy to have spent some time looking for the right response.
And now, I turn the talking stick over to you:
Who do you call just to hear what they’ll make of something? What is it about them?
What’s the best reply you thought of too late?
If you had a column of your own, what would you call it?
I’d love to hear about your own back-of-the-theater moments in the comments. The conversations here are a highlight of my week. If you enjoy these essays, a like, a share, or a restack helps new readers find them, and a paid subscription helps stoke the creative fires. Thank you for being here, whatever you came for.
Afterward:
Connections are made in how we communicate. Ask questions that make room for people, and a community starts to feel like one.
Try this:
This week, swap “What do (or did) you do?” for “What’s been holding your attention lately?” Ask a neighbor, a cousin, the person next to you at the pharmacy, then listen carefully, even if the answer is about leaf blowers. Bonus points if you get a story you didn’t see coming. No elevator required.
See you soon!


Elizabeth, it's just uncanny that you've written this beautiful missive about writing in the everyday. Now that the election is over and I can breathe again, if only for the moment, I've been thinking about how I can ease away from the political into the sublime. I was about to use the same quote as Nan did, which tells you that we're on the same wavelength. It's not our subject as much as our voices. You've created a niche that's all your own, but it's not necessarily definable. That, too, is the beauty of it. When I said I love that I never know what I'll find when I come here, I meant that as the highest compliment.
Finding the gold in what could be an ordinary day is a talent not everyone has. And here we are, focusing, because you think about these things and so do we. I'm smiling as I write this, still early morning, as I'm about to start my day. Where will it lead? I hope somewhere where I, too, can find my own gold. ❤️
"I don’t believe we return to writers for their subjects. We’re there for their eyes, their distinctive ways of noticing, for the associations we might not make ourselves." I think our readers connect with us for you we are as people, too. I love what you write about, because the topic be a surprise, but your point of view, your way of Beggins-ing in the world is unique and I always learn something from you by looking at the world, or the situation you describe, through your eyes, and that gives me fresh perspective, compared to how I might have handled the same situation. I think you're a magnificent writer. And what do I write about? All kinds of things, and the more I write, the more I have to say, and I'm just figuring it all out as I go, and I'm letting my readers experience my evolution as a woman, a human being, a political opinionator...and might I humbly say, a bit of a comedian (which I'm digging into, as you know). Honestly, I'm Substack for connection to myself and others, for the joy it brings, and for the laughter and the all the other feelings that arise. But the friendships have been the best part. Love you, friend! xo