55 Comments
User's avatar
Jill CampbellMason's avatar

Valuable sharing

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thank you, Jill. So much to process in our world, and it comes from every angle, many of them not new. I can only hope that the pain of what we are reckoning with will evolve into readiness for transformational changes. Grateful to you for reading and commenting!

Jill CampbellMason's avatar

And THANK you for continuing so optimistically!

Teresa O’Connor's avatar

All I know is that all men definitely are not the same. Thank goodness. My husband is completely sickened by this event. And I was relieved to see so many men among the protesters at Cornell this week. What happened at that Ivy League school was shocking to anyone with a bit of morals. I would never want my daughter to attend there unless major changes are made. And the more we as a culture show our unwillingness to accept this inhumane behavior, the better for us all as a society.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thanks, friend. I'm glad you shared this. It's reassuring that your husband is on the right side of it, as is mine (though I have to wonder what Giselle Pelicot would have said about hers before...yikes!). What I'm focusing on is that good people live inside the same culture. I think the more we speak up about even minor instances, and start recognizing what we've maybe not seen before, the more likely it is that we will, as a society, be able to bring about change, and to vote accordingly.

Teresa O’Connor's avatar

Absolutely! I completely agree.

Ann Yonkers's avatar

Elizabeth,

Thank you for taking on this explosive topic and exploring all the possible whys instead of just raging about how brutal this everyday reality is. Really good work. Thank you

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

So appreciate the comment, Ann, and for seeing how getting at the why drives my thinking. There's never just one, which makes problem-solving that much more complex. Grateful for you and all the ways you continue to explore.

Rita Marie Ott's avatar

Not shouting into the void. There is so much to say on this topic, it is hard to know where to start. After the Epstein files, the Giselle Pelicot case, and my own brief experience in the Greek system 40 years ago, what happened at Cornell did not surprise me. Sickened me, but did not surprise. Throw in the rollbacks on women's rights and the rise of repressive religions teaching its members that women are to submit to men, and all I can say is that if a person is surprised by what happened at Cornell, they haven't been paying attention. The silence of all the men in all three cases (Epstein, Pelicot, Cornell) who were not directly involved but knew and kept quiet shows us that this is a systemic cultural problem, not one of a few individual bad apples. Your writing here illustrates that, too. I always appreciate your thoughtful, nuanced take on the issues we're all grappling with.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thanks for this, Rita. It means a lot. Heartbroken though I may be by what is coming forward in this case, I am also not surprised. I was, though, surprised that only about 20% of women report completed or attempted rape. As with tracing some of the origins of how we came to be this way, I believe there is far more to that number than meets the eye.

And yes, as usual, you found the rawest spot of all: that the behavior is enabled and protected by those who stay quiet. That's the systemic part that we can all work together to change. We all *must* work together to change.

Many thanks!

Eileen Dougharty's avatar

This is well considered and honest work, Elizabeth. Thanks for taking the time to string it all together. xo

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

I appreciate that so much, Eileen. Strings, glue, a few paperclips and some duct tape... It's a lot. Thank you for making time to read and think with me.

Janice Anne Wheeler's avatar

Powerful stuff, Elizabeth. I listened to this one.

At 15 I had a date that my parents were reluctant to approve...he was older, had a car. I often wondered if they realized why I never accepted another one of his phone calls, never wanted to see him again. I didn’t tell a soul for decades, covered the bruises within and without. So I would be counted in those percentages that you quote which of course don't count me or anyone else who never spoke out....are they actual or calculated? I'll look at your references.

I went to high school with the embroiled DA for Tompkins County in NY and graduated from Cornell University in 1991. 40(!!) years ago Matt was a smart, soft-spoken, homely athlete. I don't know who he is today, but was inspired to Google him.

You ask the question of why people do what we do and it's impossible to answer, no, not impossible, but often difficult, eh? I've spent much time considering your topic this week, and was intrigued by your choice of subject matter. Great minds. ~J

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thanks for listening, Janice, in all the ways that relate here, and for always taking in the content attentively.

I am so very sorry about what happened to you at 15 and for, I presume from your prolonged silence, the unwarranted shame. Heartbreaking and infuriating! I, too, wondered about the accuracy of those CDC numbers, given how many people keep silent. You'll see on the linked web page that they try to account for this in the framework they use. Based on where this essay went, I was particularly interested in this:

"Findings from NISVS indicate that millions of Americans are affected by sexual violence, stalking, and intimate partner violence every year. In addition to the immediate physical and emotional toll, a wide range of chronic physical and mental health problems are associated with these forms of violence. The impact is felt well beyond an individual victim, with substantial economic costs across victims' lifetimes due to medical care, lost work, and justice system costs."

It's so much bigger than the individual cases we find out about.

Matt Van Houten probably isn't sleeping very well right now.

Janice Anne Wheeler's avatar

I'm sure he isn't.

There has been an ignition....there is so much passion and anger at ALL the injustice right now! Good to see. ~J

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Such a potent piece of writing, MM. Thank you for sharing it. To borrow the author's word, there is much abolishing to do; it can easily overwhelm us.

I am bolstered by the current outcry and hope all who are feeling enraged and empowered will take specific action on those feelings.

Susan Baker's avatar

I was 6. He was a pediatrician. I was not the only one. I didn't have the words to tell my mom. But she knew. She didn't say anything to me. He committed suicide. When I was in college, I had a peeping Tom who exposed himself to me. I didn't have the words to tell my mom but my boyfriend raced to my side. Bad dates, too many tussles when "No" should have sufficed. Thank you Elizabeth for speaking out!

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Oh, Susan, no! I'm so sorry.

Thank *you* for speaking out, and for continuing to have a heart for good. I'm always grateful to have you as part of this community.

Kimberly Warner's avatar

This essay is brilliant Elizabeth.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thank you, Kimberly. I'm honored by your comment and grateful you're here.

Sybil Cooper's avatar

I texted back and forth about the news from Cornell with my closest college friend all weekend, surprised only that this story had managed to sustain a news cycle. This weekend, this same event will play out on every college campus in America, just as it did when we were in school. I keep struggling to put words to my feelings of rage, resignation, and resentment- it's a swirling jaded mess. She pointed out to me that "fraternity men make up 85 percent of U.S. Supreme Court justices since 1910, 63 percent of all U.S. presidential cabinet members since 1900, and, historically, 76 percent of U.S. senators and 85 percent of Fortune 500 executives ... Fraternities really do breed leaders—a cohort of young men dedicated to being loyal, being knowledgeable, and embracing the skills of leadership" to successfully protect themselves. Just focusing on raising good men, or celebrating the men who don't commit rape (or stand aside when they know an assault is happening) isn't enough. As a society, we all have to move to a place where the balance of power is not stacked towards protecting the men.

Melody Schultz's avatar

Your comment about fraternity men making up 85% of the Supreme Court is chilling in that two of the current justices are rapists / sexual assault participants : Thomas and Kavanaugh . They both made a mockery of the women who were brave enough to confront them during confirmation hearings.

Thankfully, not all men are rapists -and writing that sickens me , because I can’t help wondering how many ‘good’ men do nothing to stop the ones who aren’t?

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Agreed, Melody. I'm glad Sybil shared those stats.

Epstein, Thomas and Kavanaugh were in my early essay drafts. How telling it is that I took them out of the final cut because "everyone already knows those stories."

Not all men are rapists, but many are well placed to speak up when it’s inconvenient, and that’s where change starts. Women, too, in certain instances, but not without buy in from the "good guys." We've shouldered this burden on our own long enough. It's an all hands on deck situation, don't you think?

Thank you for the comment.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

"...to successfully protect themselves." Exactly this. Thank you, Sybil.

Between waves of fury and determination, I am overcome with despondence and desperation. How can this and so many interconnected issues still be the lead story now, today, when we know better? On the other hand, have we not always known better?

I mentioned the devil emoji in the Snapchat message, but I opted to not call attention to the cringe / embarrassed emoji ( 🫣 ) used by the guy who asked "shop still open?"

I'm old enough to not get the modern nuances in emoji culture, so I googled it to be sure I was in the right zone: "This emoji conveys a mix of emotions such as shyness, embarrassment, or intrigue. It's perfect for moments when you want to hide but can't resist a curious glance. People use it to depict scenarios where they're feeling bashful, scared, or irresistibly captivated by something they cannot help but look at."

They knew it was wrong. Clearly there's no doing better, despite the knowing, and in fact we've regressed. Like the removal of Confederate statues, it's past time to bring it down.

darrell parsons's avatar

Thank you for writing this. I can’t know how it feels to be a woman or girl in this world. I only know that I feel deep sadness for my granddaughters and their friends who have to negotiate it. We work as hard as we can to give them what might be helpful to them. It often feels like shouting into the wind. I am grateful that you have written this, that women share their stories, and that “Jane Doe“ hasn’t given up.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Darrell, I can't know what it feels like to be any woman other than myself, but I suspect I speak for others when I say I appreciate men like you who continue to try. Writing this is one of the ways I can contribute something. I hope many will be moved to find their own paths to doing the same.

Thank you so much for reading and making time to share your thoughts here.

Melody Schultz's avatar

Thank you for writing about this , Elizabeth . I just watched ‘We Need to Talk About Cosby’ last night . A man who had such a great reputation as an upstanding actor, comedian , family man- all the while drugging and raping women for Decades. Privilege. Entitlement. Celebrity. Power . Control .

I’m nearly disgusted by the lot of them ( men) , although I still recognize that not All men are like this , but what slays me is how you never hear about any of the good ones stopping the bad ones .

Regardless of what a woman( or girl for that matter) looks like , or how she acts or dresses - None of them wants to be raped , or sexually assaulted - that’s on the men - Period .

If we were in a matriarchal society , I wonder what our lives would be like? Certainly better than being treated like ‘merchandise’

Thanks again ❤️

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thinking about Bill Cosby also makes me queasy. Talk about perverse! I grew up listening to his records. My brothers and I still catch ourselves quoting lines from them almost reflexively. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

I hear you on the disgust. My husband has an intervention story from his college days that I cling to; from the sound of it, he helped avert a disaster for a young woman. While it reminds me that men can and do step in, evidence clearly points to the fact that we have nowhere to go but up on that one. Real behavior change happens when men face immediate social consequences, like losing the respect or inclusion of their peers. While laws can deter actions, it’s the shift in daily friend-group expectations that actually changes attitudes and mindsets. This is where we've got to focus our attention. Are you listening, men??

Sabrina Sehbai's avatar

I really appreciated your honesty in this piece. Really. Really. It was such a calm, open-hearted reflection that saw the forest for the trees, unflinchingly.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Thank you, Sabrina, for reading, commenting, and joining in with the Chicken Scratch community. It looks like we have a lot in common (line drawn logos, even), and I am always grateful to connect with other curiosity-driven readers. Finding a way through the noise is hard work but becomes little easier in the company of others on similar paths.

Sabrina Sehbai's avatar

Happy to be here, and indeed that we have much in common. May curiosity and a desire to sift through the noise keep up going xoxo

Wendy's avatar

Is this the essay you mentioned on the heels of mine? There are so many uncomfortable aspects to beauty and the conformity of being in a group (who are the fish swimming the in the water that some of us are beginning to see). And the rapes, and how that's tied to our objectification...just an onslaught. Epstein, Motherless, Gisèle Pelicot, Fordingbridge, Cornell, the leaders in our own government. Add to it, the malevolence of inviting someone we are at war with to bomb (blue) American cities...I feel as if there's a boulder on my heart. Today, I had a hard time finding a place where I went to meet with other artists. An hour drive took an hour and a half and I felt like crying. I am frayed.

Beth T (BethOfAus)'s avatar

Sending hugs. Take care dear soul.

Wendy's avatar

Thank you for your kindness, Beth. ❤️

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Yes, it is that essay, Wendy, and it's still overwhelming even now that it's out in the world. While I know there are communities and countries experiencing much worse, the social and emotional fabric here has been shredded. One thing that keeps me going is the acknowledgement that we desperately need transformative change and the simultaneous awareness that people rarely change until they have no other choice. And so, I hope. I hope that on the other side of this madness is awakening.

Your list brings up so much anger for me; to think those are just the current ones! Please go gently through your days, keep drawing, keep writing, and cry it out when you can. Sending hugs.

Wendy's avatar

It is a lot to hold. Everything in your essay. The packaging of us. I am afraid that things aren't quite bad enough that we fall in the "no other choice" category. I keep thinking of "the devil you know." People resist change because it could be worse. We have been herded in a direction, but how much of that was easy because it tapped into very normal human insecurities? You can't tell someone to value themselves, and then suddenly, they do. It's a journey. It's taking a really long time. Are you ok? Sending hugs and love back to you.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

I'm okay. Just becoming more and more vocal in my day to day dealings. Not in a harsh way, really. More the kind of conversations that have taken place here, diving in without worrying so much about whether I'm going to step in it or not.

You're so right, Wendy—we aren't yet at the "no other choice" stage. And I fear what life will look like if we get there. So I press on with trying to make it as good as I can while I can. I'm incredibly grateful to have folks like you in my midst.

Wendy's avatar

Those conversations need to be had. Until they’re the majority, not just the fringe. They are hard things for a lot of people to think about. I’m trying to make this as good as I can, too, while doing the things I’d rather not do to set us on a better course. Super glad you’re beside me.

Amy Cowen's avatar

That sounds like quite the volunteer stint, Elizabeth, but one that gave you an interesting afternoon to juxtapose against the rest of this. While systems can change, it seems that there has been an attempt to change this one for years and years and years. The threads of hegemonic patriarchy are everywhere. This: "Patriarchy is extraordinarily good at making itself look like ordinary life."

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

You're right, Amy. We've clung to this system for centuries because it benefits so many so well. I can only imagine that people felt similarly during the Suffrage, Civil War, or Civil Rights eras, and beyond. Look at what was achieved, and yet look at stayed the same—patriarchy! It's like a damned zombie!!

I suppose where my thinking takes me, and where I hope it helps lead others, is becoming less unconscious of the ways we sustain it and more deliberate about where we're willing and able to interrupt it.

Thanks for your thoughts, Amy. I hear you, and I swing wildly between perseverance and despondence.

Kay's avatar

Thank you for this powerful post, Elizabeth.

As you say - the behaviour spoken of here, is enabled and protected by those who stay quiet.

I don’t know either exactly what change involves. But for change to happen, it will take men as well as women working to effect it.

Elizabeth Beggins's avatar

Absolutely, Kay. I work in agriculture, so I'm familiar with pressing on against deeply entrenched systems. Incremental change is really all we can ever hope for, and still it takes commitments from across social, political and environmental sectors.

Thank you so much for naming that and for spending time here at Chicken Scratch this week.

Kay's avatar

Thank you for posting, Elizabeth.